ChatGPT变革“人机共生”教育生态的潜在困境和纾解策略——基于哈贝马斯的交往行为理论

Potential Challenges and Relief Strategies of ChatGPT in Transforming the Human-computer Symbiotic Educational Ecosystem——Based on Habermas's Theory of Communicative Action

  • 摘要: ChatGPT正在开拓人机交互的新领域,引发人机协同共生教育生态的重大变革。基于哈贝马斯的交往行为理论,本文批判分析ChatGPT的语言特征,厘清智能技术遮蔽在语言表征下的“类人理解力”,并以此为焦点分析ChatGPT变革“人机共生”教育生态的潜在困境和纾解策略。在潜在困境下,ChatGPT变革教育生态的“并联共生”模式为:教育主体以是否确知交往对象的身份为基准,派生出顺应工具行为和交往行为的双轨制路径,并以“人类移情”赋能“机器理解”为枢纽,疏通工具行为通往交往行为的渠道。与此同时,工具行为存在次第引发教育生态“阻隔”“疏离”“价值异化”“道德弱化”甚至“系统失衡”等危机的可能性。满足理想的“人机共生”交往条件、构建多模态开放系统、创新教育评价体系、完善技术伦理规范等应对策略可以纾解工具行为引发的困境。

     

    Abstract: ChatGPT is pioneering new frontiers in human-computer interaction and triggering significant transformations in the human-computer collaborative educational ecosystem. Based on Habermas's theory of communicative action, this paper critically analyzes the linguistic characteristics of ChatGPT, clarifies the "quasi-human comprehension" concealed beneath the language representation of intelligent technology, and uses this as a focal point to project the potential challenges and relief strategies of ChatGPT in transforming the human-computer symbiotic educational ecosystem. Under these potential challenges, the "parallel symbiosis" model of ChatGPT's transformation of the educational ecosystem is revealed. That is, educational agents, based on whether they are aware of the identity of their communication partners, derive a dual-track path that conforms to instrumental action and communicative action, and uses "human empathy" to empower "machine understanding" as a pivot to unblock the channel from instrumental action to communicative action. Meanwhile, instrumental action may successively trigger crises such as "isolation", "alienation", "value distortion", "moral weakening", and even "systemic imbalance" in the educational ecosystem. These challenges need to be addressed through strategies such as meeting the ideal conditions for human-computer symbiotic communication, constructing a multimodal open system, innovating the educational evaluation system, and improving technical ethical norms.

     

/

返回文章
返回